What's the Deal with Coffee Cup Recycling?
Author: Brad Gray
Coffee cups. Recyclable or not? Well unfortunately it’s not a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer at the moment. So why does the confusion exist and what is the best way to dispose of your disposable cups?
Whether coffee cups are recyclable or not is one of the most controversial questions in the recycling industry at the moment. The cups are made by covering cardboard with a thin layer of plastic to make it waterproof. The cups are pretty much the same material as milk and juice cartons which are accepted in recycling almost everywhere.
How the cardboard and plastic behave in the recycling process – particularly during pulping - is the source of all the controversy. If the cardboard fibres remain attached to the plastic they can’t be turned back into paper products and therefore become a waste product.
Some recycling processors consider disposable cups a contaminant and have teamed up with workplaces, particularly large businesses, and some councils to tell people to keep coffee cups out of the recycling. There has also been a fair bit of media, like the ABC’s War on Waste, and social media that says cups are not recyclable.
However, there have been reports by both industry groups and major recyclers which clearly state that coffee cups are recyclable in co-mingled and mixed paper bins. A September 2015 report on the recyclability of poly-coated (i.e. plastic coated) fibre prepared for the Australian Packaging Covenant said that (hot) coffee cups “were more likely to break down in the pulping process because of their material composition [as they have thin] polyethylene coatings, they are more susceptible to water ingress, more rapid breakdown and improved recovery of fibre.”
So as you can see there are confusing and conflicting messages. The industry is talking about these issues and will hopefully come to a consensus soon.
So, What To Do?
- At Work: Two of the general recycling rules are ‘if in doubt, leave it out’ and ‘follow the rules’. Both of which apply here. If your workplace says ‘no cups in the recycling’ it’s best to follow that rule. If the recycling contractor considers cups a contaminant they may levy fines on bins with cups in them.
- At Home: If your council accepts milk and juice cartons their systems should be able to handle the odd coffee cup without any problem. If you have a single coffee on the way home from the bakery, for example, then it’s safe to say it can go in your home comingled recycling without much concern. And according to GreenChip, the developer of the PREP tool, the simple act of flattening paper cups mean they will move though the sorting station in the best way.
- Switch to Reusable: Best of all, ditch the disposable (and all this confusion) and switch to a reusable cup. A study in Canada found that, in terms of the energy used in manufacturing, re-usable cups break-even with paper cups fairly quickly. It takes just 15 uses for a glass cup to break even, it’s 17 for a plastic re-usable and 39 for ceramic. So the more often you use your re-usable the lower the overall impact.
Put a Lid on It
The lids are widely considered recyclable and can generally go in the plastic or comingled recycling bin.
Brad was Planet Ark's Head of Campaigns for 10 years. He trained and worked as a history and geography teacher before moving into the health education sector for 14 years. With a strong passion for human environments, Brad started with Planet Ark in 2007 as Recycling Programs Manager.
- Going plastic free: what does it take? »
What does it take to go plastic free, even for a month, and what are some of the issues to consider? One of our staff me... More »
- Wriggly Solution To Plastic Pollution: The Caterpillar That Eats Plastic »
In the face of serious concerns that by 2050 there could be more plastic in our oceans than fish, scientists may have fo... More »
- 14 Items You Can Recycle - But Probably Aren't (Part Two) »
In the second part of this article we look at seven more items that most Australians could be recycling - but probably a... More »
- Soft Plastic - Scrunch and Recycle »
Soft plastics, the kind that can be scrunched into a ball, are among the biggest problems in the kerbside recycling syst... More »
- Test Your Recycling Knowledge! »
How much of this skip bin can be recycled? Win prizes and test your knowledge with the Recycle Right Quiz... More »
- Awake to the Fun of Recycling »
"There are so many bits and bobs in products out there that I didn't know could be recycled and I until I started workin... More »